Indiana News

Charlie White Report: "Apparent But Rebuttable" Evidence of Voter Fraud

October report compiled by White's predecessor urged further review


Charlie White
Charlie White

An October report compiled under Secretary of State Charlie White's predecessor concludes there's enough evidence White's voter registration was illegal to "warrant public concern."

But the more than 200-page report by then-deputy Secretary of State Chris Naylor notes the evidence available from the public record is "not comprehensive" and could be rebutted. It urges the two special prosecutors who investigated White's registration to seek sworn testimony to clarify several points, especially whether White's use of his ex-wife's address was intentional or what White has called a "silly mistake."

White's office released the report Thursday after receiving clearance to do so from state Inspector General David Thomas. Former Secretary of State Todd Rokita had rejected Democratic Party demands to release it, on confidentiality grounds.

Special prosecutors John Dowd and Dan Sigler indicted White on seven counts in March. They had agreed with Rokita the report was an investigative record, and had asked Thomas to probe whether White violated ethics rules by reviewing it after taking office.

Thomas says the law leaves it to the officeholder's discretion whether to treat the report as confidential. He says not only did White violate no law or rule by reviewing it, but that Rokita would have been breaking the law had he not turned it over upon leaving office in January.

White's office referred all comment to spokesman A-J Feeney-Ruiz, who says the office has wanted to release the report all along to let the public draw its own conclusions. He characterizes the report as "inconclusive," and notes Rokita and Naylor did not question White or any other witnesses.

The report walks through which criminal laws could be applicable to White's case, and how the evidence stacks up. Feeney-Ruiz describes it as "Indiana Election Law for Dummies."

Naylor notes the same set of facts, if proved, could justify either felony or misdemeanor charges. A felony conviction would force White to resign, but a misdemeanor conviction would allow him to continue in office.

A Hamilton County grand jury returned seven felony counts, including two not addressed in the report: a mortgage-fraud count accusing White of using the same incorrect address on a mortgage application, and a theft count tied to the salary White received as a Fishers Town Council member after moving out of his district.

The report is posted on White's website at

» Challenge to White's Candidacy to Be Resolved in June (5-4-11)
» Judge Will Set Deadline to Resolve Charlie White Election Dispute (4-28-11)
» Democrats Will Gain Secretary of State's Office If White Is Disqualified (4-27-11)
» Judge Orders GOP to Get Charlie White Challenge Off Square One (4-26-11)
» Republicans Could Lose Major-Party Status (4-19-11)
» White Recuses Himself from Case Against Him (4-13-11)
» Judge Reverses Decision on Secretary of State (4-7-11)
» Decision Expected Thursday in Dems' Challenge of White Candidacy (4-6-11)
» Secretary of State Appoints New Deputy (3-14-11)
» Deputy Secretary of State Resigns (3-12-11)
» White Pleads Not Guilty; Trial Set for August (3-11-11)
» Professor Breaks Down Charges Against Secretary of State (3-7-11)
» Secretary of State Will Not Resign (3-3-11)
» Governor Calls for Secretary of State to Step Down (3-3-11)
» Secretary of State Indicted on Voter Fraud Charges (3-3-11)
» White Sworn In As Secretary of State (1-6-11)
» Democrats Demand Second Chance to Unseat White As Secretary of State (12-31-10)
» State to Review Wrong-Precinct Voting (12-14-10)
» Recount Commission Dismisses Dems' SOS Challenge (12-13-10)
» Secretary of State-Elect Tries Again to Halt Election Challenge (12-6-10)
» Panel to Meet Sunday on Secretary of State Race (11-29-10)
» Indiana Democrats Say Runner-Up Should Get Secretary Job (11-19-10)
» Democrats File Complaint Against SOS Candidate (10-28-10)
» Special Prosecutors In Charlie White Case (10-11-10)
» Special Prosecutor to Look Into Candidate's Alleged Voter Fraud (10-1-10)
» GOP Fires Back in Secretary of State Battle (9-30-10)
» Democrats Claim Fraud in GOP Nominee's Residency Mistake (9-28-10)
» White Campaign Responds To Allegations (9-22-10)
» Secretary of State Nominee Resigns Council Seat (9-21-10)

Copyright by © 2012. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

WIBC News Traffic Hotline

If you see a news story or traffic tie-up, let us know!

Call:  317.637.6397


Send photos:


Garrison Chicks Abdul At Large Abdul At Large