Listen Live

INDIANAPOLIS – More than five years have passed since the murders of two young girls in a small Indiana town. Nobody has been arrested in the case but details have slowly been revealed about a man accused of using a fake online persona to speak with one of the victims prior to her death.

Abigail “Abby” Williams and Liberty “Libby” German were found murdered on February 14, 2017. Their murders are still unsolved.

In December 2021, Indiana State Police requested tips regarding a fake profile under the name “Anthony_Shots,” saying the creator of the profile was using pictures of a male model to chat with the two girls.

The following day, WISH-TV was able to uncover court documents showing a man named Kegan Kline had been connected to the “Anthony_Shots” account and that law enforcement had been looking into him since 2017.

WISH-TV’s investigation team received a transcript of an interview between Kline and investigators from 2020.

The interview transcript is from a questioning in a child porn case that reveals police believe two people were using the “Anthony_Shots” profile. That account is being investigated by State Police in the murders of Abby and Libby.

The following details were uncovered in the transcripts:

  • Kline admitted to using the “Anthony_Shots” account to get sexual photos and videos of underage girls
  • A second person had access to the account, but the name was redacted from the documents
  • Kline admitted to having contact with Libby German
  • Kline and German spoke for a few hours at a sleepover through the “Anthony_Shots” account
  • Kline denied exchanging photos and messages with German
  • Kline messaged one of German’s friends after the murder saying “O.M.G. what happened?”
  • A review of Kline’s phone history revealed “non-stop searches of the Delphi case.”
  • Kline was sending snap chat messages to German after he was aware of her death
  • Kline failed two polygraph tests that he was given in the Delphi murder investigation
  • Investigators asked Kline “why would you after you failed the polygraph about knowing about the Delphi investigation, come home, delete your Snapchat and your Instagram, which you used to communicate with Libby and then you searched, ‘how long does D.N.A last?’ Why would you do that?”
  • Several times throughout the interview, Kline denied killing Abby and Libby

It is important to note that neither investigators nor Kline were under oath during these interviews, and law enforcement is allowed to exaggerate facts during questioning.

Kline is due back in court on April 14. He faces 30 charges including child porn, child solicitation and obstruction of justice.