Blend Bar Cigar
3981 E 82nd St, Indianapolis
Tony’s pick: Davidoff Dominicana
Carmack’s Cigar Shop
822 Logan St, Noblesville
Tony’s pick: Oliva Melanio
Maduro on Main
11 S. Main, Fortville
Premier Arms
3754 S Green St, Brownsburg
Tony’s pick: CAO Amazon Basin
Smoker’s Choice Cigar Bar
729 N. Green Street, Brownsburg
Tony’s pick: Arturo Fuente King T
The Smoke Pit
221 West Main Street, Greenwood
Tony’s pick: Blackbird’s, The Finch